Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe, Shelter Island NY

Near places

More seafood restaurants close to Shelter Island NY

• Claudios Clam Bar - Greenport

  111 Main St, Greenport, NY, Greenport, 11944

  Closed - 2.67 miles away

• El Paseo - Greenport

  111 Main St, Greenport, 11944

  Closed - 2.67 miles away

Other restaurants close to Shelter Island NY

• Bella Vita Pizza and Restaurant - Shelter Island

  Italian Restaurant

  53 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, 11964

  Closed - 0.46 miles away

• Maria's Kitchen - Shelter Island

  Mexican Restaurant

  55 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, 11964

  Closed - 0.48 miles away

• The Islander - Shelter Island

  Comfort Food Restaurant

  63 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, 11964

  Closed - 0.57 miles away

• Vine Street Caf� - Shelter Island

  American Restaurant

  41 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island, 11964

  Closed - 0.88 miles away

• The 1901 Grill - Shelter Island Heights

  Bar and Grill

  26 Sunnyside Ave, Shelter Island Heights, 11965

  Closed - 1.28 miles away

• Vue - Shelter Island Heights

  American Restaurant

  26 Sunnyside Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, 11965

  Closed - 1.28 miles away

• Goat Hill Shelter Island - Shelter Island Heights

  26 Sunnyside Dr, Shelter Island Heights, 11965

  Closed - 1.28 miles away

• Fresh The Restaurant - Shelter Island

  American Restaurant

  26 Sunnyside Drive, Shelter Island, 11964

  Closed - 1.35 miles away

• Chequit Inn Restaurant - Shelter Island Heights, Long Island

  American Restaurant

  23 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Long Island, 11965

  Closed - 1.47 miles away

• Sunset Beach Restaurant - Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Isle Hts

  American Restaurant

  37 Shore Road, Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Isle Hts, 11965

  Closed - 1.47 miles away

• La Maison Blanche - Shelter Island Heights, Long Island

  Fine Dining Restaurant

  11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, Long Island, 11965

  Closed - 1.47 miles away

• Stars Cafe - Shelter Island

  Latin American Restaurant

  17 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island, 11964

  Closed - 1.49 miles away

• Sunset Beach Resort - Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island

  Belgian Restaurant

  35 Rocky Shore Road, Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island, 11965

  Closed - 1.54 miles away

• 18 Bay - Shelter Island

  Fine Dining Restaurant

  23 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, 11964

  Closed - 2.28 miles away

• Pizzeria Baccano - Greenport

  Fast Food Restaurant

  111 Main St, Greenport, 11944

  Closed - 2.69 miles away

• The Shipyard - Greenport

  Bar and Grill

  102 Main St, Greenport, 11944

  Closed - 2.71 miles away

• Scrimshaw - Greenport

  Fine Dining Restaurant

  102 Main Street, Greenport, 11944

  Closed - 2.73 miles away

• Lucharitos - Greenport

  Mexican Restaurant

  119 Main Street, Greenport, 11944

  Closed - 2.74 miles away