Shelter Island New York

Restaurants

American Restaurants 12 Italian Restaurants 7 Fine Dining Restaurants 4 French Restaurants 3 Asian Restaurants 3 Mexican Restaurants 3 Oyster Bar Restaurants 2 Health Food Restaurants 1 Fish and Chips Restaurants 1 Organic Restaurants 1 Barbecue Restaurants 1 Latin American Restaurants 1 Hamburger Restaurants 1 Breakfast Restaurants 1 Belgian Restaurants 1 Chinese Restaurants 1 Delivery Restaurants 1 Fast Food Restaurants 1

Add more details to this place

Other Amenities in Shelter Island

Movie theaters 3 Takeouts 15 Home improvement 89

Additional Amenity Sub-categories in Shelter Island, New York

← Back to all amenities in Shelter Island, New York

For each listing we have opening times, address, phone number, reviews and photos

Local Information

Distances in these cards are measured from the centre of the 11964 ZIP area.

State or areaNew York

ZIP code11964

Telephone code631

Time zoneEastern Time (EST/EDT)

Daylight through the yearLongest day (Jun 21): 15 h 8 min5:17 am – 8:25 pmShortest day (Dec 21): 9 h 13 min7:10 am – 4:23 pm

Sun todaySunrise –Sunset –

People2,906 residentsin the ZIP code areaMedian age 43.61,087 householdsMedian household income $134,620Median home value $1,078,50093% of homes owner-occupiedMedian property tax $5,530 a yearSource: US Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020-2024

Work and commuting8.4% unemployment rate62% of adults are in the labour force, 1,350 employedMain industries: transport, warehousing and utilities 24%, professional and business services 19%, education and health care 13%Average commute 36 minutes52% drive alone, 6% car-pool, 16% take public transport, 26% work from homeSource: US Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020-2024, ZIP area

Education and languages61% of adults have a bachelor's degree or higher87% finished high school, 36% hold a graduate degreeLanguages at home: English only 81%, Spanish 19%11% speak English less than very wellSource: US Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020-2024, ZIP area

ClimateWarmest month July: highs 82°F, lows 67°FColdest month February: highs 39°F, lows 25°F50 in of rain a year, on about 78 dayswettest month December27 in of snow a year, on about 11 days3 days above 90°F, 73 nights below freezing in a typical yearSource: NOAA 1991-2020 Climate Normals, Orient Pt Sp station, 6 mi away; rain from Bridgehampton

Nearby landmarksShelter Islandisland · 1.9 miNorthwest Harborbay · 3.2 miMashomack Preservepark · 1.3 miDering Harborbay · 3.6 miLong Beachbeach · 3.6 miCrescent Beachbeach · 3.8 miSource: USGS Geographic Names Information System

Parks and public landsShelter Island State Tidal Wetlandstate conservation land · 1.5 miSag Harbor Golf Course State Parkstate park · 4.0 miElizabeth Alexandra Morton National Wildlife Refugenational wildlife refuge · 4.6 mi · 177 acresTown of Shelter Island Landpark · 2.1 mi · 111 acresOrient Beach State Parkstate park · 4.9 mi · 1,142 acresRam Island County Parkpark · 2.8 miSource: USGS Protected Areas Database (PAD-US)

Earthquakes5 of magnitude 3 or more within 50 miles since 19700 of magnitude 4+, 0 of magnitude 5+Largest: magnitude 3.8 on 21 Oct 198116 mi away, near Madison Center, ConnecticutMost recent: magnitude 3.0 on 9 Apr 201948 mi awaySource: USGS Earthquake Catalog

Natural hazardsOverall risk Relatively HighSuffolk County, NY, compared with all US countiesHigher-risk hazardsWinter weather Very HighCoastal flooding Very HighLightning Very HighIce storm Very HighSource: FEMA National Risk Index (county level)

Air quality73% of days had good air in 2025265 of 365 days measured95 moderate, 3 unhealthy for sensitive groups, 2 unhealthy daysMedian index 41, worst day 154main pollutant: ozoneSource: US EPA Air Quality Index, Suffolk County monitors, NY

Internet at home55% of households have a broadband subscription53% have cable, fibre or DSL2% rely on a mobile data plan alone12% have no internet at homeSource: US Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020-2024

Drinking waterShelter Island Heights Associationserves 500 people from ground waterNo health-based violations since 202129 monitoring or reporting violations since 2021Source: US EPA Safe Drinking Water Information System, largest system serving the town

Elevation1 ft0 m below sea levelSource: USGS 3D Elevation Program

Local servicesHospitalEastern Long Island Hospital5.2 miPost officeShelter Island Post Office2.4 miTown hallNorth Haven Village Hall1.4 miPoliceShelter Island Police Department2.3 miFire stationShelter Island Fire Station2.4 miSource: USGS National Structures Dataset

Getting aroundAirportMontauk Airport MTP20 miMajor airportBradley International Airport BDL65 miInterstateI-9518 miUS highwayUS 117 miAmtrakOld Saybrook, CT OSB18 miRailGreenportMTA Long Island Rail Road (MTA LIRR)4.7 miSources: OurAirports; US Census Bureau TIGER roads; Bureau of Transportation Statistics NTAD

Distances in these cards are measured from the centre of the 11964 ZIP area.

American Restaurants

American Restaurants in Shelter Island

Bay Burger - Sag Harbor
1742 Bridgehampton Sag Harbor Turnpike, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 4.4 mi
Estia's Little Kitchen - Sag Harbor
1615 Bridgehampton Sag Harbor Turnpike, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 4.7 mi
BSmith's - Sag Harbor
1 Long Wharf Street, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 3.2 mi
Beacon - Sag Harbor
8 West Water Street, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 3.3 mi
Noah's - Greenport
136 Front Street, Greenport, 11944 · 4.8 mi
First and South - Greenport
100 South Street, Greenport, 11944 · 4.8 mi
Front Street Station - Greenport
212 Front Street, Greenport, 11944 · 4.8 mi
Vine Street Café - Shelter Island
41 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island, 11964 · 1.4 mi
Chequit Inn Restaurant - Shelter Island Heights, Long Island
23 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Long Island, 11965 · 3.5 mi
Sunset Beach Restaurant - Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Isle Hts
37 Shore Road, Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Isle Hts, 11965 · 3.5 mi
Page at 63 Main - Sag Harbor
63 Main Street, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 3.4 mi
Fresh The Restaurant - Shelter Island
26 Sunnyside Drive, Shelter Island, 11964 · 3.5 mi

Italian Restaurants

Italian Restaurants in Shelter Island

Il Capuccino Ristorante - Sag Harbor
30 Madison Street, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 3.5 mi
Tutto Il Giorno - Sag Harbor
6 Bay Street, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 3.3 mi
Pagano's Little Italian Place - Greenport
110 Front Street, Greenport, 11944 · 4.8 mi
Conca D'Oro - Sag Harbor
103 Main Street, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 3.4 mi
Emilio's - Greenport
400 Main Street, Greenport, 11944 · 4.9 mi
Bella Vita Pizza and Restaurant - Shelter Island
53 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, 11964 · 2.4 mi
Cappelletti Italian Grill - Sag Harbor
3284 Noyac Road, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 4.5 mi

Fine Dining Restaurants

Fine Dining Restaurants in Shelter Island

Scrimshaw - Greenport
102 Main Street, Greenport, 11944 · 4.7 mi
18 Bay - Shelter Island
23 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, 11964 · right here
Peconic Landing - Greenport
1500 Brecknock Road, Greenport, 11944 · 4.8 mi
La Maison Blanche - Shelter Island Heights, Long Island
11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, Long Island, 11965 · 3.5 mi

French Restaurants

French Restaurants in Shelter Island

Cuvee Seafood & Grille - Greenport
326 Front Street, Greenport, 11944 · 4.8 mi
American Hotel Restaurant - Sag Harbor
49 Main Street, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 3.4 mi
Pomme Cafe East - Sag Harbor
16 Main Street, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 3.3 mi

Asian Restaurants

Asian Restaurants in Shelter Island

Sen - Sag Harbor
23 Main Street, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 3.3 mi
Phao Restaurant - Sag Harbor
29 Main Street, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 3.3 mi
Phao - Sag Harbor, Long Island
29 Main Street, Sag Harbor, Long Island, 11963 · 3.4 mi

Mexican Restaurants

Mexican Restaurants in Shelter Island

La Super Rica - Sag Harbor
1 Main Street, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 3.3 mi
Rinconsito Hispano - Greenport
7 Sterlington Commons, Greenport, 11944 · 4.8 mi
Lucharitos - Greenport
119 Main Street, Greenport, 11944 · 4.7 mi

Oyster Bar Restaurants

Oyster Bar Restaurants in Shelter Island

Blue Islands Restaurant - Greenport
36 Front Street, Greenport, 11944 · 4.7 mi
North Fork Oyster Co - Greenport
300 Main Street, Greenport, 11944 · 4.8 mi

Health Food Restaurants

Health Food Restaurants in Shelter Island

Juicy Naam - Sag Harbor
51 Division Street, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 3.6 mi

Fish and Chips Restaurants

Fish and Chips Restaurants in Shelter Island

East End Prime Meat Butcher and Seafood Market Sag Harbor - Sag Harbor
51 Division Street, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 3.4 mi

Organic Restaurants

Organic Restaurants in Shelter Island

Cilantro's - Sag Harbor
138 Division Street, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 3.6 mi

Barbecue Restaurants

Barbecue Restaurants in Shelter Island

BBQ Bill's - Greenport
47 Front Street, Greenport, 11944 · 4.7 mi

Latin American Restaurants

Latin American Restaurants in Shelter Island

Stars Cafe - Shelter Island
17 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island, 11964 · 3.6 mi

Hamburger Restaurants

Hamburger Restaurants in Shelter Island

Loft Restaurant - Greenport
48 Front Street, Greenport, 11944 · 4.7 mi

Breakfast Restaurants

Breakfast Restaurants in Shelter Island

Coronet Luncheonette - Greenport
2 Front Street, Greenport, 11944 · 4.7 mi

Belgian Restaurants

Belgian Restaurants in Shelter Island

Sunset Beach Resort - Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island
35 Rocky Shore Road, Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island, 11965 · 3.7 mi

Chinese Restaurants

Chinese Restaurants in Shelter Island

China Kitchen - Greenport
206 Front Street, Greenport, 11944 · 4.8 mi

Delivery Restaurants

Delivery Restaurants in Shelter Island

LT Burger - Sag Harbor
62 Main Street, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 3.4 mi

Fast Food Restaurants

Fast Food Restaurants in Shelter Island

Walerburger - Sag Harbor
Bridgehampton Tpke, Sag Harbor, 11963 · 3.6 mi

Add venues to this section

Best reviews

Top american restaurants in Shelter Island

American Restaurants yet to be reviewed

Top italian restaurants in Shelter Island

Italian Restaurants yet to be reviewed

Top fine dining restaurants in Shelter Island

Fine Dining Restaurants yet to be reviewed

Top french restaurants in Shelter Island

French Restaurants yet to be reviewed

Top asian restaurants in Shelter Island

Asian Restaurants yet to be reviewed

Top mexican restaurants in Shelter Island

Mexican Restaurants yet to be reviewed

Top oyster bar restaurants in Shelter Island

Oyster Bar Restaurants yet to be reviewed

Top health food restaurants in Shelter Island

Health Food Restaurants yet to be reviewed

Top fish and chips restaurants in Shelter Island

Fish and Chips Restaurants yet to be reviewed

Top organic restaurants in Shelter Island

Organic Restaurants yet to be reviewed

Top barbecue restaurants in Shelter Island

Barbecue Restaurants yet to be reviewed

Top latin american restaurants in Shelter Island

Latin American Restaurants yet to be reviewed

Top hamburger restaurants in Shelter Island

Hamburger Restaurants yet to be reviewed

Top breakfast restaurants in Shelter Island

Breakfast Restaurants yet to be reviewed

Top belgian restaurants in Shelter Island

Belgian Restaurants yet to be reviewed

Top chinese restaurants in Shelter Island

Chinese Restaurants yet to be reviewed

Top delivery restaurants in Shelter Island

Delivery Restaurants yet to be reviewed

Top fast food restaurants in Shelter Island

Fast Food Restaurants yet to be reviewed