Paul's Pizza, West Coxsackie NY

Opening hours

2 reviews posted but no photos posted yet - be the first to post!

Find other open restaurants near Paul's Pizza, West Coxsackie NY

Wednesday 30th September 2026 12:03 pm

Reviews

• Icky
  Bubba Carpenter Reviewed 30th March 2012 10:45 PM
• If there was an option for 0 stars, it would have gotten that. We ordered from Paul's tonight to get home to the most disgusting, old, soggy chicken wings imaginable. The worst part was calling to tell the manager what we experienced. We were told that "they were sorry that we didn't like their food", & "that it sat for 10 minutes before it was picked up". Let me say this, I am 32 years old and have ordered food from many places in my life. I have never called to complain about food until now because of how gross it was. Their response holds no weight and they did nothing to take my complaint seriously. The chicken wings were absolutely uneatable, and the warm bleu cheese tasted like horseradish and vinegar were thrown together. I will say that the calzones are very good but you cannot keep a business forever with poor customer service. They are one of the only places in town to order from but with the opening of some new places, they might have a run for their money if these new places can provide good customer service. The price of the food was a little ridiculous as well. $9 for a dozen of old chicken wings is way overpriced and barely meets standards for human consumption. After this experience, I will never order from there as long as I live, nor will I tell anybody I know to ever go there.
  Jeremy Smith Reviewed 30th March 2012 10:45 PM

Add a review

Pictures

Photos of Paul's Pizza

No photos posted yet
Be the first to post a photo!

Add a photo

Parking near

Boat N Rv, 12634 State Route 9w, West Coxsackie, NY (0.42 miles) Phone (518) 731-9900

Pilot Travel Center, 995 Route 9, Castleton On Hudson, NY (14.17 miles) Phone (518) 732-7272

Exit 10 Self-Storage Inc, 1550 Columbia Tpke, Castleton On Hudson, NY (14.26 miles) Phone (518) 477-4140

Petrol 9W Company, 294 Route 9w, Glenmont, NY (14.77 miles) Phone (518) 434-9582

Store Away Self-Storage, 520 Columbia Tpke, East Greenbush, NY (15.39 miles) Phone (518) 477-7772

Train stations near

AMTRAK-HUD (10.06 miles)

National Railroad Passenger (17.65 miles)

ATM cash points near

These cash machines are near to Paul's Pizza Restaurant

• BANK OF GREENE COUNTY, 370 Mansion St, West Coxsackie, NY

  2.45 miles away

• First Niagara, 20 Faith Plz, Ravena, NY

  4.86 miles away

Local places

Paul's Pizza is listed as a local restaurant for the following areas

West Coxsackie, Coxsackie, Stuyvesant, Hannacroix, New Baltimore, Climax